Does it matter?

Check and share here for the latest fishing reports.
User avatar
tamiron
Posts: 1317
Joined: Sun Aug 28, 2011 7:11 pm
Species: trout, salmon
Location: Granger, IN
Contact:

Does it matter?

Post by tamiron »

Curiosity is getting the best of me :D

With only the information on the forum to guide me, I have read more than one post about the Inland Sea having fish that contain 2 & 3 inch alewives and more than one post referring to 4 inch plus smelt and, in one case, adult alewives coming out of fish in the Main Lake.

How many anglers have tried to "match the hatch" and what are the results? I know a major derby is coming up, but ... if size doesn't matter how can the results matter either?

Many, many years ago, before the "introduction" of alewives, among a few anglers (who refused to say) it was common knowledge that the #3 Honeybee was responsible for a large number of Derby placements. At least in your tournament pre-fishing time, you might consider leaving your comfort zone, and trying larger lures mixed in your spread and even sharing the results. I mean, does size really matter
Lures designed by fishermen for fishermen
User avatar
fishingmachine
Posts: 860
Joined: Tue Aug 30, 2011 2:48 pm
Species: salmon,Lake trout
Location: Rutland

Re: Does it matter?

Post by fishingmachine »

trolling 5/26 in 100 feet of water,surface at 56 degrees,started at 30 feet,dropped rigger all the way to the bottom only to have it fire,running a big 41/2" laker spoon in a gaudy green and orange color.wham,cannonball hit bottom and a fish nailed it,very surprised to see a 20" salmon on the lure.the lure was what I would consider a laker lure.could be the salmon chased it on the way down,but still a surprise to me
User avatar
tamiron
Posts: 1317
Joined: Sun Aug 28, 2011 7:11 pm
Species: trout, salmon
Location: Granger, IN
Contact:

Re: Does it matter?

Post by tamiron »

fishingmachine wrote:trolling 5/26 in 100 feet of water,surface at 56 degrees,started at 30 feet,dropped rigger all the way to the bottom only to have it fire,running a big 41/2" laker spoon in a gaudy green and orange color.wham,cannonball hit bottom and a fish nailed it,very surprised to see a 20" salmon on the lure.the lure was what I would consider a laker lure.could be the salmon chased it on the way down,but still a surprise to me

Where it came from we'll never know ... but we know it hit the big spoon and may have followed it a long way too!
Lures designed by fishermen for fishermen
User avatar
fishingmachine
Posts: 860
Joined: Tue Aug 30, 2011 2:48 pm
Species: salmon,Lake trout
Location: Rutland

Re: Does it matter?

Post by fishingmachine »

I hope all is well with you ,Jim. I taped up a bunch of #1 copper bees with different shades of purple last week,put pics on facebook,they were HOT
User avatar
tamiron
Posts: 1317
Joined: Sun Aug 28, 2011 7:11 pm
Species: trout, salmon
Location: Granger, IN
Contact:

Re: Does it matter?

Post by tamiron »

fishingmachine wrote:I hope all is well with you ,Jim. I taped up a bunch of #1 copper bees with different shades of purple last week,put pics on facebook,they were HOT
For those of us who don't have facebook, can you post them here? It would be nice for the newcomers to see what they can do with tape and paint.
Lures designed by fishermen for fishermen
User avatar
jimbow
Posts: 632
Joined: Sun May 24, 2015 7:18 am
Species: Salmon & anything that swims

Re: Does it matter?

Post by jimbow »

I guess SIZE must matter, this past week I caught a beautiful 28 1/2" 8 lb salmon :o while using a custom hand painted (Nascar) #3 Honey Bee :D ....Match the hatch...


Image
images upload

Image
how to use print screen
mrwalleye
Posts: 33
Joined: Wed Oct 05, 2011 11:11 am

Re: Does it matter?

Post by mrwalleye »

I always run a few bigger than normal spoons/ stick baits for salmon. Last trip out we caught 3 salmon, Two were on Michigan Stinger Standard (3-3/4") and one on a Lucky Craft Pointer 100SP which is a 4" stick bait. The winning Salmon for the 2015 Frostbite Shootout was caught on a Honeybee #3 (3.81")
I know big fish bite small lures and small fish bite large lures, but I believe bigger is better.
User avatar
tamiron
Posts: 1317
Joined: Sun Aug 28, 2011 7:11 pm
Species: trout, salmon
Location: Granger, IN
Contact:

Re: Does it matter?

Post by tamiron »

mrwalleye wrote:I always run a few bigger than normal spoons/ stick baits for salmon. Last trip out we caught 3 salmon, Two were on Michigan Stinger Standard (3-3/4") and one on a Lucky Craft Pointer 100SP which is a 4" stick bait. The winning Salmon for the 2015 Frostbite Shootout was caught on a Honeybee #3 (3.81")
I know big fish bite small lures and small fish bite large lures, but I believe bigger is better.
Remember confidence in one's program always out fishes change for the sake of change!
Lures designed by fishermen for fishermen
User avatar
Hairbone
Posts: 970
Joined: Wed Aug 31, 2011 5:05 pm
Species: Bluegill
Location: Whallons Bay...They Are ALWAYS Biting... ;)

Re: Does it matter?

Post by Hairbone »

jimbow wrote:I guess SIZE must matter, this past week I caught a beautiful 28 1/2" 8 lb salmon :o while using a custom hand painted (Nascar) #3 Honey Bee :D ....Match the hatch...


Image
images upload

Image
how to use print screen

Hmmm. I need a #3 like that
User avatar
Hairbone
Posts: 970
Joined: Wed Aug 31, 2011 5:05 pm
Species: Bluegill
Location: Whallons Bay...They Are ALWAYS Biting... ;)

Re: Does it matter?

Post by Hairbone »

jimbow wrote:I guess SIZE must matter, this past week I caught a beautiful 28 1/2" 8 lb salmon :o while using a custom hand painted (Nascar) #3 Honey Bee :D ....Match the hatch...


Image
images upload

Image
how to use print screen

Hmmm. I need a #3 like that
User avatar
Hairbone
Posts: 970
Joined: Wed Aug 31, 2011 5:05 pm
Species: Bluegill
Location: Whallons Bay...They Are ALWAYS Biting... ;)

Re: Does it matter?

Post by Hairbone »

Tried out some large evil eyes as I bought a few from Norms this past week. Smoking hot on the lakers!
User avatar
tamiron
Posts: 1317
Joined: Sun Aug 28, 2011 7:11 pm
Species: trout, salmon
Location: Granger, IN
Contact:

Re: Does it matter?

Post by tamiron »

Hairbone wrote:Tried out some large evil eyes as I bought a few from Norms this past week. Smoking hot on the lakers!
If they had large alewives in them ....
Lures designed by fishermen for fishermen
User avatar
Hairbone
Posts: 970
Joined: Wed Aug 31, 2011 5:05 pm
Species: Bluegill
Location: Whallons Bay...They Are ALWAYS Biting... ;)

Re: Does it matter?

Post by Hairbone »

tamiron wrote:
Hairbone wrote:Tried out some large evil eyes as I bought a few from Norms this past week. Smoking hot on the lakers!
If they had large alewives in them ....

;)
User avatar
jimbow
Posts: 632
Joined: Sun May 24, 2015 7:18 am
Species: Salmon & anything that swims

Re: Does it matter?

Post by jimbow »

You like my paint job on the spoon heh... Hairbone???? Sorry I painted it, not Jim, but I also had good luck with Mottled Green which is available....
User avatar
Hairbone
Posts: 970
Joined: Wed Aug 31, 2011 5:05 pm
Species: Bluegill
Location: Whallons Bay...They Are ALWAYS Biting... ;)

Re: Does it matter?

Post by Hairbone »

jimbow wrote:You like my paint job on the spoon heh... Hairbone???? Sorry I painted it, not Jim, but I also had good luck with Mottled Green which is available....
Nice! Gonna open my own lure company if Jim doesn't start working 24 hours a day 7 days 365 a year to keep us tackle mongers fully stocked with the latest & greatest lures :D You know to be successful you have to have every cool name spoon on the shelf :lol: Running lots of old school bees with great success ;)
Post Reply